Serving the Plain City & Jerome Village community with premium handcrafted Italian favorites.
At Jan & Tony's Pizza, we believe that great pizza starts with fresh, simple ingredients. Located in the heart of Plain City, we've spent years perfecting our recipes to bring local food lovers the best Italian-American dining experience possible.
Our journey began with a simple goal: to create a cozy, local spot where families can gather and enjoy hot, freshly baked food. From our thin-crust pizzas loaded with smoky bacon, to our hot toasted Italian subs and rich, comforting pasta dishes, every item on our menu is a testament to our dedication to flavor and community.
We are proud to serve our friends in Jerome Village, Plain City, and surrounding neighborhoods. When you order from us, you're not just getting a meal—you are sharing in a local Ohio tradition.
Browse Our Menu
Our pizza dough and marinara sauces are prepared fresh in our kitchen every single morning. We never use frozen dough or pre-packaged bases.
Our chefs stretch every single pizza crust by hand, resulting in a thin, light crust with the perfect balance of crispy edges and tender bite.
We believe in supporting the community that supports us. We source local ingredients, sponsor neighborhood events, and feed local schools.
We don't cut corners. We believe that using premium, pure components is the only way to bake a pizza that you'll remember.
High-gluten unbleached wheat flour, fermented for 24 hours to develop rich flavor notes and perfect air pockets.
Sweet, red vine-ripened tomatoes crushed and blended with fresh basil, oregano, and garlic for our secret sauce.
100% whole milk mozzarella cheese blocks shredded fresh daily. No anti-caking agents, just pure cheese melt.
